Bucky’s past and rehabilitation make him unsuitable to be the next Captain America, but he is fit to lead the Thunderbolts. The responsibility and expectations of being Captain America would hinder Bucky’s healing process and be unfair to him. Meanwhile, being the Thunderbolts’ leader could be a therapeutic experience. Bucky’s ability to lead the Thunderbolts depends on his progress in processing his past and making amends, but he has the potential to be an effective leader.
Becoming Captain America?
Bucky, like Steve Rogers, is a man out of time who was brainwashed by HYDRA to become the Winter Soldier. Since being saved, he has been focused on his healing journey and making amends for his past crimes. With Steve gone, Bucky is now on his own, and Marvel Studios has the opportunity to further explore his character. He is in a unique position in the Multiverse Saga due to his rich history and connection to the past. His next endeavor is to lead the Thunderbolts, a team composed of various MCU characters.
The fact that Bucky can lead the Thunderbolts raises questions about why he couldn’t be the next Captain America. It has been explained that burdening Bucky with the responsibility of being Captain America would impede his rehabilitation process. However, leading the Thunderbolts could be therapeutic for him, as he would be among characters who also have a checkered past. He wouldn’t have to deal with judgment from others because they all have their own faults.
The responsibility of being the next Captain America comes with pressure to live up to Steve’s impeccable record, something that Bucky will never be able to achieve due to his past. It would be unfair to burden him with such expectations when it would be virtually impossible for him to meet them. On the other hand, leading the Thunderbolts allows Bucky to forge his own path and learn from his teammates, who also have their own redemption arcs.
However, whether Bucky is truly ready to lead the Thunderbolts is uncertain. His latest outing in The Falcon and the Winter Soldier showed him still in the process of making amends for his past sins. His ability to lead the Thunderbolts will depend on how he has spent his time since then. Once he fully processes his past, there is no doubt that he has the potential to be an effective leader in the team.
In conclusion, Bucky’s past and ongoing rehabilitation make him unsuitable to be the next Captain America. However, he is fit to lead the Thunderbolts, where he can continue his healing journey alongside other characters with similar experiences. Bucky’s ability to lead the Thunderbolts depends on his progress in processing his past and making amends, but he has the potential to be an effective leader in the team.